(Season 4, Episode 6)
I really, really didn’t want to watch an episode of Ted whining about the loss of his relationship with Stella. It turns out that I didn’t have to, thanks to the solid writing and the Barney-isms throughout. Ted mourns Stella through denial, which leads to some very funny flashback scenes about who the gang would each avoid if they were to run into them.
Not only was this episode funny, it was also meaningful and poignant. After the jump, I’ll break it all down for you.
Ted figured that if he could avoid Stella, he could avoid the pain of being left at the altar. When Ted puts the gang on the spot and reveals the people they’d avoid, we end up with some classic flashback scenes.
Lily ruins Gasser’s popularity by blaming her fart on him. C’mon, everyone has done that once in their lives, right? So just relating to this scene makes it funny, but seeing Lily as a semi-Goth teen was priceless.
Of course Barney would use a prison inmate to get regularly scheduled sex. The priceless part of this scene? The catfight, of course.
Ah, it explains so much to know that Robin’s father raised her as a boy: her penchant for firearms, for one. Seeing Robin dressed as a boy, making out with her teammate as the light dawns on her father that he doesn’t actually have a son was a riot, but the way the gang responded to her with sympathy was well done.
Now, for my favorite Barney-isms:
One last observation of a funny moment: the impetus for Ted finally getting angry at Stella was the fact that she was going to make him move to NJ, when instead she moved to the city for Tony. Yep, NJ would do it every time.
This episode was actually pretty deep, when you think about the title, “Happily Ever After,” and the lesson Ted shared with his kids at the end of the episode: you’ve got to just let the anger go for it to truly be gone. This was accentuated by the fact that the gang all held onto their anger with the people they would hide under the table from: Gasser, Becca and Robin’s father.
Pretty solid writing for a half-hour sitcom, eh?
I agree … another well done episode … and a tidy end to the Stella story
Sure pretty solid. It’s HIMYM for god’s sake! That’s why we love it! Best sitcom currently on TV. PERIOD!
:-D
I actually found Ted’s reasoning for getting angry to be the weak link in the episode.
Who is to say that Stella WAS actually living in NY. Perhaps it was just a trial to work out their relationship. Maybe they were just there for the night. IIRC, wasn’t Stella’s child in school back in NJ? Ted made a huge assumption thinking Stella moved to NY.
Akbar:
I don’t know… I don’t know if the writers could have made it more clear that she had moved (I’m not saying they made it 100% clear, I’m literally saying I don’t know how they could have made it clear).
I think it was worth it just for the bit of it being the reason that he got mad. That could definately have been the tipping point for Ted.
Great episode.
I like the fact that they are cutting the cord on Stella. The problem with the show is that it needed a shelf life to begin with so that we as the viewer can handle being tossed around a bit. If we knew in 3 seasons that we would be all set with the end then I would gladly watch much in the same manner that I watch 24 to see how it will end. To prolong this into perpetuity to hit 100 shows, while it would be great for all the NPH witticisms seems like a redux of Friends and a definite dilution of the first season’s humor.